S’MAC (short for Sarita’s Mac and Cheese) is a tiny, casual eatery on East 12th that’ll hit you with the smell of butter, comfort, and happiness the moment you open the front door. The orange and yellow theme and the bright overhead lights only add to the warmth of the atmosphere (well, until you get to the grouchy cashier, that is).
But back to the happy part: After spending a few minutes salivating over the 12 recommended dishes, ranging from the simple American (American and cheddar cheese) to the Alpine (gruyere and slab bacon) to the Garden Lite (lite cheddar, parmesan, roasted cauliflower, portabello mushrooms, roasted garlic, broccoli, and scallions), then moving on to the overwhelming realization that you can also create your own masterpiece (choose from 14 cheeses and 20 mix-ins), you can stumble wide-eyed to the counter to place your order, specifying size (mac is served in 4 skillet sizes: nosh, major munch, mongo, and partay), noodle type (elbow or whole wheat), and breadcrumbs or no breadcrumbs. You then stand with your number waiting to claim the next table that opens up, while eying everyone else’s food to make sure you made the best choice possible.
I went with the American, keeping it simple to ensure that I could judge the place based on the basics without getting thrown off by crazy mix-ins like olives and buffalo chicken. My dining partner went out on a limb and ordered the Parisienne, made with creamy brie, roasted figs and shiitake mushrooms, and fresh rosemary. I was pleased with my choice, as Stephanie’s pasta was good for one bite, but a little too intense for a full meal. My only regret is not going for the major munch size, though I’m sure my body appreciates being spared such gluttony.